Tickets :: Comment on [#8816] includes a fr_FR.po translation instead of fr.po

* Your Email Address
* Spam protection	Enter the letters below: .__ .__ . ,.__.. . [ __[__) \./ [__]\ / [_./\| \ \| \| \| \/
Comment	>>> Using a country part in a translation file is a discouraged practice >>> except in very few cases (such as pt_BR). >> >> Discouraged by whom? > > Quoting again (from the same bug): > <quote> > For the vast majority of languages, using a country > part is irrelevant. Canadians speaks French the same way than French > do....or Austrians speak German the same way you do (or so closely > that having separate translations is irrelevant). > > Less than a rule, this is general common practice. This does not > prevent people to use more specialized translations when they feel > it's appropriate. > > </quote> > > Also, using country part only when relevant avoid the use of aliases > like in nls.php and don't attach a language to a country. > > >> >>> Using a fr_FR.po file instead of a fr.po file prevents users of fr_CA, >>> fr_BE, fr_LU, fr_CH and all other existing and future locales for >>> French to benefit from the French translation of the program. >> >> The Horde NLS class is taking care of this already. > > I didn't know that. This bug is then less relevant, it is just to > remove the need to maintain $nls['aliases']. > >>> The language does not vary among countries and, again, this is not the >>> general practice for programs localization. >> >> But it may vary. There's different wordings between Swiss, Austrian, >> and German German for example, or probably between the Iberian >> Spanish and South American Spanish, let alone the different spelling >> between British and American English. >> Including the country name right from the start we are prepared for >> adding country-specific alternate translations, and don't have to >> rename the general-purpose translation when we add one. > > Yes, but with the no-country-by-default way of doing, you can put > only certain strings in the country specific po. > > Quoting again (from the same bug): > <quote> > For instance, the software can have a fr.po file which will be used as > a general French translation....and a few fr_XX files for more > specialized translations. But the common practice is first having a > fr.po file (and, more important, a fr.mo file after build) before more > specialized files. > </quote> > > Regards > > Mathieu >
Attachment
Watch this ticket

Saved Queries